Digital Transparency and the Future of Mormonism

Joseph Smith

Joseph Smith, Founder and Prophet of the Mormon Faith

Within the last few days, historians of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints have released images of an egg-sized stone that resembles a large pecan.

The stone is purportedly the seer stone that LDS Founder and Prophet Joseph Smith used to translate the Book of Mormon, the primary sacred text of the Mormon faith.

The release of these images and other documents are part of an effort by the church to render its history more transparent in an age when transparency has become the basis on which the fortunes of institutions in 21st century rise and fall.

Within the last few years, I’ve developed a keen fascination for this phenomenon.  The LDS, of course, is not the only institution dealing with this new reality. The transparency that has grown out of the digital communications revolution is exposing many facets of life that were once considered off limits, if not sacrosanct. But among all the major religions of the world, Mormonism appears to be especially vulnerable to this phenomenon, largely because so many accounts exposing both the good and bad facets of the life of Joseph Smith have survived.

Digital transparency seems to be creating a genuine crisis of faith within Mormonism, though for decades, the church has been beset with challenges from members who have emerged deeply troubled after researching the early origins of their faith.

What’s playing out within Mormonism within the last few decades closely parallels what has occurred in other comparatively closed religious cultures within American society. Members of these faith traditions become more affluent and send more of their young people go off to pursue higher education, acquiring the critical investigative skills shared by all college-educated Americans.

Inevitably, a few of these young people become religious scholars, often using the critical investigative tools they have acquired through their graduate and post-graduate education to ask probing questions about their own faith traditions.

Indeed, the first major crisis within Mormonism was sparked by historian Fawn McKay Brodie, a so-called Mormon princess and the niece of an LDS apostle David O. McKay, who later became the ninth president of the church.

Brodie was a child prodigy who graduated from Utah State University at 19 and then received a scholarship to study history at the University of Chicago. She eventually used her training to write the first scholarly biography of Founder/Prophet Joseph Smith: “No Man Knows My History.”

It was not a very flattering account. Indeed, Brodie’s portrayal of Smith sparked a crisis in the Church that has not abated within the last 60 years.

Other Mormon scholars have also subjected church teachings and documents to the same rigorous standards of scholarship and have turned up similar disturbing findings. Among them is Grant H. Palmer, who holds an M.A. in history from Brigham Young University and spent a 34-year career in the LDS Church Educational System.

Like Brodie, Grant perceived inconsistencies in Mormon doctrines that prompted him to delve deeply in the Church’s early origins. He eventually shared his findings in “An Insider’s View of Mormon Origins,” published in 2002. The book raises a number of questions about Smith’s original intentions, including how he constructed the Book of Mormon using accounts from the King James Version, the evangelical revival unfolding within his native region, Smith family experiences, and the anti-Masonic movement.

Discoveries, once confined to trained historians, many of whom had strong incentives to share them only with other trained specialists, are slowly being disseminated by digital media to inquiring laypersons.

Indeed, a few years ago, the highest ranking LDS official in Sweden, Hans Mattson, related the spiritual crisis he suffered after many of his members confronted him with their own concerns about the origins of the faith.

After undertaking his own investigation and uncovering discrepancies, Mattson felt as if his spiritual foundation was crumbling under his feet.

As the New York Times reported, the LDS is confronted with growing numbers of followers around the world who experience serious crises of faith after conducting their own Internet investigations.

This rising tide of doubt has prompted the church to articulate a new response.  The Times reports that the church already has released seven volumes of papers concerning the life of Smith, asserting that transparency, candor and historical accuracy are the only effective and honorable ways to deal with these challenges.


About Jim Langcuster

A Southern late-Baby Boomer whose post-retirement focus is on building a post-racial, post-Confederate Southern regional identity. If the election of 2016 underscored one thing, it is that this country is intractably divided and that radical devolution of power to localities and states is the only way to save the American Union.
This entry was posted in American Religion, The Passing Scene and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Digital Transparency and the Future of Mormonism

  1. shematwater says:

    First, I had to chuckle when you said “critical investigative skills shared by all college-educated Americans.” In my experience most college-educated Americans don’t have any skills in critical investigation but simply swallow whatever their teachers tell them. Any person who dares challenge the teacher in a critically thoughtful way is shut down.

    As to the rest, there is a crisis of faith, but that is because God is purging the church. God is allowing these things to come to light so that the truly faithful can be separated from the rest in preparation of Zion and the second coming.

    Also, I don’t know much about Palmer, but Brodie was discredited a scholar with her book about Thomas Jefferson.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s